California Academy of Sciences and Presidio Trust repopulate sand dunes with relative of extinct Xerces Blue butterfly

SAN FRANCISCO, CA (April 15, 2024) — In a historic reintroduction that further restores native ecosystems in San Francisco, the California Academy of Sciences and Presidio Trust released Silvery Blue butterflies (Glaucopsyche lygdamus)—the closest living relative of the extinct Xerces Blue butterfly (G. xerces)—last week in the sand dunes of the Presidio, a national park site.

The butterfly’s successful release in San Francisco was made possible by the restoration of more than 50 acres of the Presidio’s dune habitat and the identification of a compatible “surrogate” species that will revive an ecosystem function lost with the human-driven extinction of the Xerces Blue.

“This isn’t a Jurassic Park-style de-extinction project, but it will have a major impact. The Silvery Blue will act as an ecological ‘stand-in’ for the Xerces Blue, performing the same ecosystem functions as both a pollinator and a critical member of the food web,” says Durrell Kapan, PhD, a senior research fellow and the lead Academy researcher on the project. “To ensure a successful reintroduction, we needed to identify a subpopulation that shared genetic and ecological similarities with the Xerces Blue: a sand dune specialist that is well-adapted to the cool, foggy climate of San Francisco and relies on the same host plant, deerweed (Acmispon glaber).”

“The Xerces Blue project is a perfect example of the Academy’s mission to regenerate the natural world through science, learning, and collaboration. It demonstrates that even in a city, species can return to—and thrive in—places where they were previously driven away, provided they have healthy nature to support them,” says Academy Executive Director Scott Sampson, PhD. “The lessons we learn from the Silvery Blue here in our backyard could serve as a model for regenerating other ecosystems across California and beyond.”

Learning from our past
The Xerces Blue was the first butterfly species in the United States to be driven to extinction from habitat loss caused by human development. Its entire population was confined to sand dunes that extended from the Presidio through Ocean Beach to Fort Funston in what is now San Francisco’s Richmond and Sunset neighborhoods. Though the species went extinct more than 80 years ago, the iconic butterfly—whose name inspired the Xerces Society for Invertebrate Conservation—serves as a reminder of the importance of protecting invertebrates and their habitats.

“The loss of even a single species can have ripple effects across local ecosystems,” says Phoebe Parker-Shames, PhD, Presidio Trust wildlife ecologist. “Enhancing biodiversity is critical to healthy, functioning ecosystems and the people that rely on them, so that we are more resilient to climate change, invasive species, and other negative human impacts.”

Finding an ecological stand-in for the Xerces Blue
To fill the gap that the Xerces Blue left behind when it disappeared in 1943, researchers first tapped into the California Academy of Sciences’ invaluable collection of nearly 46 million scientific specimens. Utilizing the Academy’s in-house genetic sequencing capabilities, scientists analyzed Xerces Blue specimens—some dating back more than a century—to better understand its genome. Three years of niche modeling and fieldwork confirmed researchers’ prediction that a group of Silvery Blues about 100 miles south of San Francisco could successfully fill the ecological niche left by the Xerces Blue. “We were excited to find thriving populations of Silvery Blues from the sandy coastal scrub habitat at foggy sites in Monterey County that we predict are the best candidates for translocation to the Presidio,” Kapan says.

With a healthy dune habitat and plenty of deerweed to support the Silvery Blues in the Presidio, researchers from the Academy and Creekside Science secured permission to gather butterflies from UCSC’s Fort Ord Natural Reserve and Garrapata State Park in Monterey County and transport them to San Francisco. Each butterfly enjoyed a few drops of fruit punch-flavored Gatorade to sustain them on the drive—a tried-and-true method for butterfly translocation—and was marked for future identification.

The team will continue to track their movements using high-resolution photographs to identify their markings, similar to identifying individual whales by their flukes. “Our hope is that these new residents will lay their eggs and return in even higher numbers next spring,” says Lew Stringer, associate director of natural resources at the Presidio Trust.

Restoring the Presidio sand dunes
“We are so pleased that 30 years of habitat restoration in the Presidio has recreated the natural conditions necessary to support the Silvery Blues,” says Jean Fraser, CEO of the Presidio Trust. “Stewarding the natural resources of the park is one of our primary values, and it’s great to see indications that the ecosystem is increasingly healthy and more resilient. This return is another example of how humans and wildlife don’t just co-exist, we thrive together in the Presidio.”

For over three decades, the Presidio Trust and the Golden Gate National Recreation Area have worked to ecologically restore the former military base and increase overall biodiversity. Park stewards have facilitated the return of native and endangered plants and have successfully reintroduced several endemic species to the Presidio, from rough-skinned newts (Taricha granulosa) and western pond turtles (Actinemys marmorata) to the San Francisco forktail damselfly (Ischnura gemina) and the variable checkerspot butterfly (Euphydryas chalcedona). Now teeming with life, the Presidio is a known biodiversity hotspot in San Francisco.

Regeneration through partnership
The four-year project involved a collaborative team of scientists and park stewards from the Academy, Presidio Trust, Creekside Science, Golden Gate National Recreation Area, and Revive & Restore. Funding for two critical stages of the project, initial gene sequencing and early fieldwork and later ecological niche modeling and butterfly translocations, was provided by Revive & Restore and the McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity at the Florida Museum of Natural History respectively. The Academy, Presidio Trust, and Golden Gate National Recreation Area are also part of Reimagining San Francisco, an urban nature alliance of more than 40 organizations that aims to increase biodiversity and equitable access to nature throughout the city.

On exhibit
Xerces Blue butterfly specimens can be viewed at the Academy’s Hidden Wonders exhibit.

Assets
Hi-res images and footage here. 

Media contacts
Megan Ely, mely@calacademy.org
Lisa Petrie, lpetrie@presidiotrust.gov